Best Under Eye Masks (Updated November 2024)

Are you tired of looking in the mirror each day and seeing dark circles, fine lines, and puffiness? Let Buyer's Report help you find a real solution, with the best under eye masks that have been reviewed and rated by our experts.

1
Best Overall
Moisturizing Eye Masks Grace & Stella

Moisturizing Eye Masks

10.0 (1,903 reviews)
  • Award-winning mask for dry under-eye areas
  • Hyaluronic acid helps reduces dark circles, puffiness, & wrinkles
  • Features cooling & anti-inflammatory properties to brighten & revitalize
  • Unique hydrogel design optimizes moisture absorption
  • 100% cruelty-free, vegan, sulfate-free, & paraben-free
CHECK PRICE Amazon logo

Picked by 223 people today

2
Energizing Gold Under Eye Masks Grace & Stella

Energizing Gold Under Eye Masks

9.9 (1,197 reviews)
  • Nutrient-filled under eye masks that instantly de-puff & rejuvenate
  • Formulated with sea moss to energize tired eyes
  • Instantly locks-in moisture to help decrease fine lines & wrinkles
  • Uses only clean ingredients that are gentle on sensitive skin
  • Includes 48 masks & requires only 20 minutes for noticeable results
CHECK PRICE Amazon logo

Picked by 285 people today

3
Restoring Eye Masks Grace & Stella

Restoring Eye Masks

9.8 (3,270 reviews)
  • Overnight masks designed to rejuvenate & restore fatigued under eyes
  • Infused with potent retinol to plump the skin & reduce fine lines
  • Unique blend of sea moss, ceramide, & fatty acids eliminate dark circles
  • Enjoy noticeable results in as little as 5-7 days
  • Formula is 100% vegan & 100% cruelty-free
CHECK PRICE Amazon logo

Picked by 236 people today

4
Energizing Under Eye Masks Grace & Stella

Energizing Under Eye Masks

9.7 (3,786 reviews)
  • Nutrient-filled under eye masks that instantly de-puff & rejuvenate
  • Formulated with sea moss to energize tired eyes
  • Instantly locks-in moisture to help decrease fine lines & wrinkles
  • Uses only clean ingredients that are gentle on sensitive skin
  • Includes 24 masks & requires only 20 minutes for noticeable results
CHECK PRICE Amazon logo

Picked by 143 people today

5
Golden Glow Under Eye Patches DERMORA

Golden Glow Under Eye Patches

9.5 (3,865 reviews)
  • Specially formulated mask for puffy eyes & dark circles
  • Packed with potent ingredients for brighter & smoother skin
  • Helps to smooth out the appearance of fine lines & wrinkles
  • Sticks to all skin types & takes only 20 minutes for noticeable results
  • Includes 30 individually wrapped packages that are travel-friendly
CHECK PRICE Amazon logo

Picked by 299 people today

Top Rated Under Eye Mask

1
Best Overall
Moisturizing Eye Masks Grace & Stella

Moisturizing Eye Masks

10.0 (1,903 reviews)
  • Award-winning mask for dry under-eye areas
  • Hyaluronic acid helps reduces dark circles, puffiness, & wrinkles
  • Features cooling & anti-inflammatory properties to brighten & revitalize
  • Unique hydrogel design optimizes moisture absorption
  • 100% cruelty-free, vegan, sulfate-free, & paraben-free
CHECK PRICE Amazon logo

Picked by 223 people today

Under Eye Masks Buyer's Guide

From dark circles to fine lines and wrinkles, there are a number of common concerns that seem to plague the delicate skin around the eyes, and addressing this problem area requires more than just a generalized skin care routine. Sure, a deep cleanser and a hydrating moisturizer is a great first step to rejuvenating and revitalizing your overall appearance, but if you want to truly tackle the effects of poor sleep, or the natural aging process, then it may be time to introduce a more targeted product into your arsenal. Thankfully, there is a wide array of specialized eye care products available on the market, and if you’ve found yourself wishing you could turn back the clock on your eyes, then an under eye mask may be the ideal solution for you. Designed to properly address the unique concerns you may have, these impressive masks can quickly transform your eye area from dull to radiant, and they don’t require much time or effort in order to be effective. 

However, not all under eye masks are the same, and there can be significant variation when it comes to the types of problems they are able to address, and what ingredients they contain. This is why it’s so important that you do some initial research before you begin trying to shop for a new product, and one of the best places to begin is with our buying guide. Created to give you all of the information you need so you can make a more informed purchasing decision, this article dives deep into the complex world of under eye masks, and provides greater insight into the ingredients you can expect to encounter, as well as the various concerns each option is meant to alleviate. Whether this is your first time buying a skin care product, or you’re a seasoned enthusiast who already has an established routine, this buying guide will empower you to make a well-informed decision as you select an under eye mask, and will ensure you walk away with the right product for your needs, whatever they may be. 

What Do Under Eye Masks Help With?

When creating the perfect skin care routine, the first thing you should always start with is what your own personal concerns are, as this is going to be different from person to person. Are you someone that tends to struggle with having very dry skin all year round? Or are you someone who is constantly blotting excess oil away from your face throughout the day? Do you struggle with dark circles under your eyes from too many late nights? Or are you starting to see the signs of aging with fine lines and wrinkles now making an appearance? Identifying these unique concerns is the only way to tailor your skin care routine so that it’s able to actually address the problems you are facing, and this is true when purchasing a moisturizer, cleanser, serum, or targeted under eye mask. However, unlike your overall skin and appearance, the under eye area can be prone to some very specific and unique concerns, and because it’s quite delicate and thin, it often shows signs of fatigue, aging, and dehydration, more prominently. Given the delicate nature of the skin around the eyes, it does require specialized care in order to correct the issue without causing additional damage, and some of the core concerns a proper under eye mask may be able to assist with include:

  • Puffiness - Typically caused by fluid retention, lack of sleep, or poor circulation, puffiness under the eyes can create a tired and swollen appearance that can significantly impact your overall look. To fix this, you’ll want to select an under eye mask that focuses on delivering cooling benefits, as well as ingredients that are known for their ability to reduce inflammation and promote circulation.
  • Dark Circles - Resulting from various factors such as poor sleep, genetics, or pigmentation issues, dark circles are one of the most common concerns people tend to have when it comes to their eyes, and these can be one of the most challenging problems to correct. If this is something you’ve found yourself struggling with, an under eye mask that focuses on brightening will be ideal, as these can reduce the discoloration while also providing nourishment to the delicate skin around the eyes.
  • Fine Lines & Wrinkles - As you age, your body will naturally undergo many changes, and one of the first areas where these changes may be noticeable is around the eye area. Because the skin is so fine and delicate, it can be extremely prone to the development of fine lines and wrinkles, and while this is unavoidable, there are under eye masks that can help reduce how noticeable they are. To really see significant changes, always reach for formulas that specifically contain collagen or retinol, as these two ingredients do an amazing job of tightening up the skin and can help improve the overall texture. 
  • Dryness - A common skin-related problem that doesn’t just limit itself to the under eye area, dryness can be particularly noticeable and irritating, especially if it’s accompanied by flaky skin or itchiness. Whether it’s related to the seasonal changes, or simply something you deal with on an on-going basis, the best way to address this problem is by looking for under eye masks that can hydrate and nourish. Any ingredient that will help attract and retain moisture is going to be essential for eliminating dryness once and for all, and will need to be used consistently in order to reap the benefits long-term.

Key Ingredients

Once you’ve successfully identified the key concerns you’re facing with your under eye area, the next step in the shopping process is going to be selecting the correct mask that includes the correct ingredients for your needs. If you hate how noticeable your fine lines and wrinkles are, for example, then you’re going to want collagen more than you’ll want niacinamide, as the former is known for its ability to promote skin elasticity, and the latter is more beneficial for sun damage. Conversely, if puffiness is your main concern, then something that contains cooling ingredients like cucumber extract or aloe vera will be better at soothing your skin than hyaluronic acid would be, as you don’t want to be drawing in excess moisture that may actually make the problem worse. Understanding the role each potential ingredient plays is the only way to ensure you actually can address your needs effectively, and some of the core components you’re likely to encounter while shopping will include:

  • Hyaluronic Acid - Hailed as one of the skincare industry's powerhouse ingredients, hyaluronic acid is a naturally occurring substance in the skin that plays a crucial role in maintaining hydration. Its ability to retain water is what makes it a popular choice for addressing dryness and promoting overall skin health, and if you want your under eye area to look plumper, less dry, or you want to reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, then this is one key component you don’t want to skip out on.
  • Retinol - A potent ingredient that’s derived from vitamin A, retinol is the go-to choice for anyone who has been struggling with hyperpigmentation, general dark circles, or noticeable fine lines and wrinkles. By accelerating cell turnover, retinol helps shed old and damaged skin cells and under eye masks that include it can quickly lead to a fresher, more youthful appearance when used consistently. 
  • Vitamin C - A powerful antioxidant that offers a range of benefits for the skin, vitamin C can be a great choice if you’ve noticed premature aging of the skin, typically caused from environmental damage. Whether it’s because you love soaking up those extra rays in the summer months, or you're exposed to environmental pollutants, the antioxidant properties of vitamin C can help counteract the effects of free radicals and protect the skin, and it can effectively brighten up your appearance to reduce potential dark spots. 
  • Caffeine - Just like how a cup of coffee can perk you up in the morning, caffeine as a skin care ingredient acts in a similar manner, and it’s a popular choice among individuals who notice their eyes tend to look tired or lackluster each day. Not only can caffeine help brighten up your under eye area, but thanks to its vasoconstrictive properties it does an amazing job of reducing puffiness and improving circulation, which can be particularly beneficial if you tend to suffer from dark circles.
  • Collagen - A crucial protein that plays a fundamental role in the structure and health of the skin, collagen is one of the most abundant proteins in the human body and it’s also one of the most common ingredients found in under eye masks. Valued for its role in maintaining skin elasticity, firmness, and hydration, this powerhouse of an ingredient is the go-to choice when you want to focus on anti-aging properties, and it does a fantastic job of not only reducing the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, but preventing them from occurring in the first place. 
  • Niacinamide - Also known as vitamin B3, niacinamide is a versatile and beneficial skincare ingredient that can be a great choice when you’re looking to improve the appearance and overall health of your under eye area. By allowing your skin to absorb and retain more moisture, this potent ingredient combats dryness and dehydration, creating a supple and smooth texture that is brighter, more even, and less likely to show signs of fatigue or stress. 
  • Aloe Vera - If you’ve ever suffered from a sunburn then you already know how amazing aloe vera is at soothing irritated skin, and this is exactly what it does when it’s included as a component inside an under eye mask formula. A very natural and effective ingredient, aloe vera is renowned for both its anti-inflammatory and moisturizing benefits, and if you tend to suffer from dryness, irritation, redness, or puffiness then this is not an ingredient you want to skip out on including. 

Final Considerations

Under eye masks can be a powerful tool for combating everything from puffiness and dark circles to fine lines and wrinkles, however, in order for these products to be truly effective, you need to be choosing the correct option for your specific skin care needs. Before incorporating under eye masks into your routine, you’ll first want to spend some time looking in the mirror to see exactly what you’re most unhappy about, and from there you can then hone in on the exact components and ingredients that will offer you the greatest benefits. Whether you need a powerful antioxidant like vitamin C for environmental damage, retinol for fine lines and wrinkles, or hyaluronic acid for intense hydration, there truly are options available that can address a wide range of common problems, and it just takes a bit of research and patience to find the solution that will work best for you. 

Once you do find that perfect under eye mask, the best thing you can do is to remain consistent with your application, as the most noticeable results will come from frequent usage instead of occasional use. It’s also essential that you follow the included directions regarding how and when to apply the masks, and you should always immediately discontinue using them if you notice any type of irritation or allergic reaction. Other than that, incorporating an under eye mask into your daily skin care routine should be a fairly simple and straightforward process, and it can be a luxurious and beneficial addition that leaves your skin looking healthier, brighter, and with a more youthful glow. With that said, an under eye mask is only one component of a proper skin care routine, so make sure you use them alongside your normal cleanser, toner, and moisturizer so that you can get the most noticeable results, long-term.